Tag Archives: Statistics

Benford’s law, or why you shouldn’t use a D10 for generating some random numbers

This applies to all games where you want to generate a random number to describe something. In many cases you cannot just use a D10 since Benford’s law says that the lower numbers will have a higher probability.

Benford's law
Benford’s law – Public domain

This law is usually true when applied to things that grow exponentially. Like the population modifier digit (the P in the PBG-number) in the extended UWP for Traveller. Why is it so? Here is an explanation! A shorter explanation is that to change the first digit from 1 to 2, the population needs to increase 100%. To change the first digit from 8 to 9 the population needs to increase 12%. This means that the population digit will stay longer at lower values and therefore the lower values will be more likely.

Something else that is interesting for Traveller, Benford’s law can also be applied on asteroid sizes, since these has been built up of smaller objects over time.

It can most likely be used for anything that is big and varied enough like the size of buildings, the size of villages or towns, the size of space ships etc…

If you use a D10 to get a first digit for something that should behave according to Benford’s law, you will create a statistical anomaly. Doing it for one, or a few planets doesn’t matter, but if you do it for┬áthe P in the PBG-number of a subsector or something larger the result you get will be very unlikely.

So stop using that D10 now! Write a simple program on your calculator or computer that calculates the first digit according to Benford’s law!

For those who still (for some reason) needs to use dice, here is a table with a distribution that is close enough to the Benford distribution using 2D6, like you should do in Traveller.

2D6First Digit

Just for fun, test Benford’s law for a number of datasets. It works!


50000 hits on the Zhodani Base front page since 1999

Many more hits on the subpages.
One of the most successful subpages is the LBB generator.

Why is such a “useless” page so popular?

Some other facts.
My traveller webpage opened in 1994. First thing posted was the first part of my Pylkah adventure. Then the page was called “Mayday”. It later changed name to “The Zhodani Base”, since that was a much cooler name…
The page was first located on a server at the Royal Institute of Technology, then it was moved to a free server, but they didn’t allow scripts and the space was limited and then they started running ads…
So the page was moved again to its present location at berka.com.

Anything else You want to know about this site?

Happy 50000!